i recently saw a blog on stumble that said the golden rule is false. if everyone did unto others as they would have done to themselves, clamity would result.

one of the instances was a E.M.T. laying on the ground with a knife in her chest. a passerby sees this and pulls it out, that bieng what they would want. the injured woman bieng a E.M.T knows that the knife was blocking a artery from bleeding, and so bleeds out and dies.

then i talked to my dad and he described a book to me called gold#9 in which a alien comes to earth and releses a dust that enforces instant karma. a person kills a police officer and dies instantly, so on and so forth.

do you think the golden rule is valid?